Paper Feedback Tool

Use this browser-based tool to get quality feedback on finance and economics papers in a referee-report format. Upload your PDF and the tool will highlight strengths, weaknesses, key assumptions, and concrete revision recommendations to help you tighten the argument and improve presentation.

This tool produces a referee-style report by extracting text from your PDF and evaluating it against common academic standards in finance/economics. The model focuses on: (1) the paper’s main research question and contribution, (2) clarity of the argument and organization, (3) validity of assumptions and identification strategy, (4) strength and interpretation of evidence/results, and (5) completeness of related literature positioning and robustness checks. It then suggests concrete revisions to improve clarity, rigor, and presentation.